Former Roma and Juventus players slam England vs Argentina referee as 'a disgrace'
Quick summary
Former Italian footballers connected to Roma and Juventus have publicly criticized the referee who officiated an England vs Argentina international match, calling the performance disgraceful.
Full article
Attributed to original sourceEngland’s World Cup semi-final defeat to Argentina sparked fury in Italy’s television studios, with Serie A legends Marco Tardelli and Paulo Roberto Falcao tearing into the officiating during an ill-tempered night in Atlanta.
According to Corriere dello Sport , the Rai 1 studio was left aghast by an ill-tempered first half in Atlanta, with Juventus great Tardelli setting the tone.
“A match that starts and already Paredes commits a nasty foul for no reason. A disgrace. Then the English too, eh… No football. Only fouls!” the 1982 World Cup winner said.
His anger extended to the appointment of the American official: “The referee did nothing. It’s incredible, I’d like to know who put him there. What does an American referee have to do with this match? He’s not up to it.”
ATLANTA, GEORGIA – JULY 15: (EDITOR’S NOTE: Image was captured using a remote camera from behind the goal.) Lautaro Martinez #22 of Argentina scores his team’s second goal past Jordan Pickford #1 of England during the FIFA World Cup 2026 Semi Final match between England and Argentina at Atlanta Stadium on July 15, 2026 in Atlanta, Georgia. (Photo by Buda Mendes/Getty Images) Falcao stunned as ‘punch’ goes unpunished as England lose to Argentina Roma icon Paulo Roberto Falcao was equally incensed, singling out one incident that went entirely unsanctioned.
“At one point someone throws a punch and the referee doesn’t even give a red. Astonishing!” the Brazilian said. “This is an assault, not a normal foul. That punch deserved a red, a full-blooded punch. I’ve never seen anything like it in football. If it carries on like this it certainly won’t finish eleven against eleven.”
Tardelli’s parting shot summed up the studio’s verdict: “The referee is incapable of managing this match, there are too many fouls, and he even booked an England player before an Argentinian. It’s a disgrace.”
Both sides did, in the end, finish with eleven men, and the drama swung emphatically late on: Anthony Gordon’s second-half opener was wiped out by Enzo Fernández’s brilliant 85th-minute equaliser before Lautaro Martínez headed home a stoppage-time winner, Lionel Messi assisting both as the holders booked a final against Spain.
Source attribution: this article content is based on the linked publisher feed/source. Chance adds independent soccer context, impact analysis, entity links, and related news.
What happened
Multiple ex-Roma and ex-Juventus players, now acting as pundits or commentators, have voiced strong criticism of the referee who handled the recent England vs Argentina fixture. The exact incidents under fire are not detailed in the headline, but the tone suggests controversial or perceived biased officiating. The criticism comes from Italian football figures, likely referencing a specific moment or pattern of decisions that affected the match outcome or flow. The backlash highlights how international officiating continues to draw scrutiny from former professionals across Europe's top leagues.
Chance analysis
Referee criticism from high-profile former players carries media weight but has limited direct impact on upcoming match predictions or team performance. The story is more relevant to discourse around officiating standards and FIFA/UEFA referee appointments than to tactical analysis. For prediction systems, this is background noise unless the same referee is assigned to a forthcoming fixture involving either England or Argentina.
No direct impact on team performance; primarily reputational pressure on the match official and possible refereeing body review.
No actionable impact on upcoming predictions unless the criticized referee is assigned to a relevant future match.